Who are you actually buying from?
The most common way parents overpay is not a scam. It is a reseller on a big store's website, charging double, on a page that looks exactly like the store.
The short answer
Before you pay, find the line that says who is selling. If it is not the store itself, compare the price with the list price. More than about 10% over, close the tab.
How it happens
- You search for the box on a big store's website.You trust the store, so you trust the result.
- The store's own stock is sold out.So the top result is the same box from an outside seller.
- The page looks like any other page on that site.Same logo, same colors, same checkout. One small line names the seller.
- The price is double.Nothing on the page says so, because the page never shows the list price.
Where to find the seller
| Website | The line to look for | What it should say |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon | Under the Buy Now button: "Ships from" and "Sold by" | "Sold by Amazon" (older listings say "Ships from and sold by Amazon.com"). If "Sold by" names anyone else it is an outside seller, even when it ships from Amazon. A Prime badge tells you nothing about the seller |
| Walmart.com | Near the price and the "Add to cart" button: "Sold and shipped by", or "Sold by ..." with "Fulfilled by Walmart" | "Sold and shipped by Walmart.com". "Fulfilled by Walmart" alone still means an outside seller. To hide them: Filters, then Retailer, then Walmart |
| Target.com | "Sold & shipped by" | No outside seller named. Outside sellers are called Target Plus partners and are named on that line |
| BestBuy.com | Above the yellow "Add to cart" button, and under "More options from Marketplace sellers" | No seller named at all: that means Best Buy itself. A name there is an outside seller |
| GameStop.com | No outside sellers | Check the price itself: in 2026 news reports showed some boxes above list price |
Checked Nov 12, 2026.
Being sold by the store is necessary, not enough: in 2026 news reports showed a few stores charging more than list price themselves on the most wanted boxes. The price check below is the real test.
Then compare the price
An example we saw on Nov 12, 2026: the Delta Reign Elite Trainer Box has a list price of $49.99. On BestBuy.com, the page for that same box showed outside sellers' offers from $99.95 to $139.99. Same box, same website, double the price or more.
Reselling is legal, and the box is usually real. You are paying their markup, nothing more. The risk rises with sellers who have few reviews or a brand-new account: see fakes and resealed packs.
If you already paid too much
Open the order page and look for the return window. Many sellers take back an unopened box. Then check the stores that sell at list price, or read what to do when it is sold out.
Questions parents ask
Why does the store allow this?
Big stores earn a fee on every sale an outside seller makes on their site.
Could the higher price be the real one?
Only if our price list shows a list price that high. A few very large boxes do cost a lot.
What about eBay and Facebook Marketplace?
Everything there is a resale, so the price is whatever the seller wants. Check the list price, then read what to check before paying.